Movie Review - Discreet (2018)
Friedkin's film and Mathews' previous work with Franco were more direct explorations of homosexuality. That exploration isn't really the case here. This movie is more of an exploration of trauma. That trauma isn't very explicitly identified. It's hinted, but one can't be totally sure. That ambiguity doesn't help this film in terms of communicating a clear and distinct message. It's instead one of the few films that's more Rorschach test than narrative. It's more opaque character-study than clear portraiture. This is compounded due to the fact that Mathews utilizes little to no dialogue, as well as long one-takes and wide-shots that keep the audience at a distance.
Alex learns that a man he thought was dead isn't dead. This visibly upsets him. He finds where this man named John lives and he goes there. John is a very elderly shell with long, grey hair. John is very tall but he seems to be suffering from some kind of brain damage or mental condition. He actually can't speak. He can barely walk and he has a constant hand-tremor. There's no explanation as to what caused John to have this condition, but it requires another man named Lyel to take care of him on his isolated and tiny house out in the middle of nowhere, far from town.
Alex begins to stalk John. He visits John and searches his property. Eventually, he starts caring for John, not emotionally but physically. He feeds John, bathes John and even puts John to bed. All the while, the sense is conveyed that John is guilty of some crime against Alex or something happened in which John did something to Alex, which has tortured Alex greatly and created a seething rage in Alex that could become murderous.
Since Mathews makes John, a brain-damaged mute, that kind of reckoning or confrontation is rendered null. Yet, this dynamic could potentially be compelling. Alex wants some kind of acknowledgment from John of what he did, a confession of sorts, but it's obvious Alex will never get it, not because the guilty man actively denies his guilt as in Hand Candy, or the recent The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017) but because John's brain damage physically prevents him, so even if John wanted to confess, he can't. This presents therefore an interesting dilemma for Alex.
What will Alex do about this situation? Early scenes suggest this will become a revenge thriller where Alex will exact his rage upon someone and not necessarily the obvious person. Aside from Mandy and Lyel, Alex interacts with a Latino named Miguel, played by João Federici, as well as a teenage boy named Zach, played by Jordan Elsass. All of whom have tense moments or encounters with Alex, which imply either of the four could also be on the receiving end of Alex's possible, murderous rage.
Because of aesthetic and even premise similarities, Mathews could have gone the way of Jeremy Saulnier's Blue Ruin (2013). Yet, it's clear that Mathews isn't interested in those kinds of genre thrills, which includes expressions of violence. It's established in the beginning that Mathews' movie is building to a violent act at the end, but Mathews has no interest in showing or depicting that act. It's a level of restraint on Mathews' part that is respectable, if not commendable.
That restraint is certainly consistent throughout the film with one glaring exception. Dropped in the middle of this movie, Mathews has a sex scene that doesn't depict intercourse but it does involve full-frontal nudity. It's also unusual given that Alex is involved but he's not physically engaged. He has a motel room where three men are invited one at a time. Alex directs each man to disrobe and place a blindfold over their eyes. The first, two men sit on the edge of the bed and fondle or caress a younger third in between them, while Alex stands in the background, watches and hosts.
Not Rated but contains full-frontal male nudity and language.
Running Time: 1 hr. and 19 mins.
In theaters in Los Angeles & select cities, starting June 1.
Available on DVD and VOD on June 5.